Welcome to Mala Fide!

 

We are delighted to present the first issue of Mala Fide: the FRI’s biannual, interdisciplinary, queer-feminist, quadrilingual academic journal dedicated to all issues relating to gender and law.

 

For the launch of Mala Fide, Prof. Dr. iur. Dr. h.c. mult. Susanne Baer, Professor of Gender Studies and former judge at the German Federal Constitutional Court, invites us to consider the law from the perspective of people’s lives rather than the norm, and to set judgements against prejudices.

 

Next are the academic articles and essays, all of which have undergone a double-blind peer review process: Dr. iur. Lucy Chebout argues that German law should base the recognition of the parent-child relationship on parental care rather than on biology. Karla Schröter, a PhD student in law, examines whether two judgments of the European Court of Human Rights on hijab bans reinforce racial capitalism. Dr. iur. Christine Sattiva-Spring, lawyer, critically analyses the criteria defined as ‘objective’ by the Swiss Federal Supreme Court to justify pay differentials. Dr. iur. Anne-Laurence Graf, lawyer, demonstrates that Swiss case law on migration law is characterised by gender stereotypes. Finally, Sarah Kiani, Doctor of History, identifies the activist, economic and political roots of the political agenda on equality in the 1980s and 1990s.

 

In the ‘Case Law & Legal Policy’ section, you will find, amongst other things, the following critical analyses: Lara Torbay, a PhD student in law, sets out her views on Switzerland’s international policy on women’s rights. Valerie Debernardi, lawyer, analyses an arbitration award granting compensation to a female footballer who was sacked because she was pregnant. Emma Lidén, lawyer, demonstrates that Swiss case law has not definitively abandoned the requirement for discretion on the part of homosexual asylum seekers when assessing the risk of persecution. Swiss parliamentary motions are commented on by Priscille Ramoni, lawyer, regarding support for victims of offences constituting a direct violation of their physical, psychological or sexual integrity, and by Maya Dougoud, associate professor, with regard to deepfakes. Rebecca Rohm, jurist, criticises a ruling by the US Supreme Court which deemed a ban on so-called ‘conversion therapies’ aimed at changing sexual orientation or gender identity to be contrary to freedom of expression. Prof. Dr. iur. Sandra Hotz, lawyer, comments on a Zurich court ruling recognising that a co-mother was able to acknowledge a child born abroad through medically assisted reproduction.

 

Finally, in the ‘Reflections’ section, the editorial board of Mala Fide presents its editorial policy in three languages, as well as the Swiss Conference of Equality Delegates’ new trilingual news portal, ‘equality law’.

 

We hope you enjoy the read!

 

The editorial board:

Alexandre Fraikin (managing editor), Sandra Hotz, Nils Kapferer, Lara Torbay und Rosemarie Weibel

 

For the launch of Mala Fide
Lydia Walter
Lydia Walter
Zita Küng
Zita Küng
Abstract

To mark the launch of Mala Fide, the FRI’s new open-access journal, Zita Küng sat down with Susanne Baer to talk about her book Rote Linien (“Red Lines”), an insider’s account of Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court. Baer argues that law should start from how people actually live, not from abstract rules. Courts, she says, are there to counter prejudice with judgment, and she warns that constitutional and human rights courts are coming under attack around the world. “The constitution doesn’t belong to the Constitutional Court or to politicians,” she says. “It belongs to the people.” This interview has been edited and condensed.

Academic Articles
Lucy Chebout
Abstract

Who are a child’s legal parents? The German term for the law of parentage (Abstammungsrecht, literally “law of descent”) might suggest that biological kinship is the primary concern. Drawing on a recent case involving mixed-up gametes, this article refutes that assumption. It also examines the strengths and weaknesses of German parentage law, including in light of legal and policy developments in recent years. The article ultimately argues for a care-based approach to legal parentage that does not centre on biological descent.

Karla Schröter
Karla Schröter
Abstract

This article examines whether the European Court of Human Rights enforced racial capitalism when deciding that public officers can be prohibited from using the hijab. It argues that the case law makes Muslim women’s employment conditional on the removal of the hijab and their adherence to Whiteness, thus barring them from working as teachers (Dahlab) or social workers (Ebrahimian). As sites of recreation for both White national identities and racialised labour hierarchies, the case law reinforces both Racial Capitalism and White Nation Fantasies (Hage) where racialised groups are placed as objects to be managed by those who embody Whiteness.

Christine Sattiva Spring
Abstract

The Swiss Federal Supreme Court sets a high bar for claimants seeking to establish pay discrimination between women and men. The so-called objective criteria it has developed to justify pay differentials, drawn largely from European case law, suggest that such discrimination will persist, despite findings to the contrary in some judgments. This article reviews how the case law has developed over the past decade.

Essays
Anne-Laurence Graf
Anne-Laurence Graf
Abstract

Swiss migration law and practice cast women in two roles, like the two faces of Janus: the “weak” woman, who would deserve protection as a victim or because she is not accompanied by her husband, and the “strong” woman, who has defied laws or practices that discriminate against women. The author argues that this binary, stereotyped view must give way to a feminist approach to migration law that treats women as legal subjects rather than as objects to be sorted into predetermined categories.

Sarah Kiani
Abstract

Sarah Kiani traces how gender equality came to be enshrined in the Swiss Federal Constitution in 1981 and later in the Gender Equality Act, which came into force in 1996. She shows how the women’s movement, together with the wider economic and political climate, drove the developments of the 1980s and especially the 1990s that put equality on Switzerland’s political agenda, with law playing a central role.

Case law & legal policy
Lara Torbay
Lara Torbay
Abstract

As the world faces an anti-feminist backlash and a retreat from multilateralism, what role does Switzerland intend to play? Drawing on the Federal Council’s replies to two recent parliamentary interpellations, the author shows that Swiss foreign policy on women’s rights remains firmly wedded to the status quo. She argues that, at a time when the international climate is increasingly hostile to human rights and women’s rights, this passivity is a political and legal choice with far-reaching consequences.

Valerie Debernardi
Valerie Debernardi
Abstract

Applying Swiss law on a subsidiary basis alongside the FIFA regulations, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) upheld a professional footballer’s claim for compensation after her club terminated her employment contract because she was pregnant. When the club learned of the pregnancy, it denied that any contract existed, even though the parties had already agreed its terms. The CAS found that a contract had been concluded and that the club’s denial amounted in substance to an unlawful termination prompted by the pregnancy. It also ordered the club to pay additional compensation for unlawfully disclosing the player’s pregnancy to third parties.

Redaktion
Abstract

The Swiss Parliament is currently considering several employment law measures with a bearing on gender equality: a Federal Council’s dispatch on ratifying two International Labour Organization (ILO) conventions, and three parliamentary proposals to improve overtime pay for part-time workers.

Redaktion
Abstract

Federal Administrative Court, judgment D-5205/2025 of 19 February 2026: If a removal would affect children, their best interests are a key factor in deciding whether it can reasonably be enforced. This follows from the requirement to interpret Swiss law in line with Switzerland’s international obligations.

Emma Lidén
Emma Lidén
Abstract

In light of recent case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), the Federal Administrative Court (FAC) has abandoned, at least in part, the discretion requirement applied to gay and lesbian asylum seekers. An analysis of this judgment and other recent decisions of the FAC shows, however, that this development is far from settled.

Priscille Ramoni
Priscille Ramoni
Abstract

This contribution examines several parliamentary proposals calling for a revision of the Federal Act of 23 March 2007 on Support for Victims of Crime. They seek to raise the caps on damages and on satisfaction, align the time limits for claims with Article 331 of the Swiss Criminal Procedure Code, and simplify the award process. More broadly, they raise the question of how the role of this revised Act should evolve and how far the state should step in, as a matter of solidarity, to compensate victims.

Rebecca Rohm
Abstract

On 31 March 2026, the US Supreme Court held that a Colorado state law banning so-called conversion therapy for minors violated the First Amendment’s guarantee of free speech. This article first provides an overview of conversion therapy and summarises the key points of the ruling, before critically assessing the Court’s reading of free speech. It closes on a hopeful note with a look at developments in Colorado itself.

Sandra Hotz
Sandra Hotz
Abstract

A recent judgment of the Administrative Court of the Canton of Zurich shows that existing law offers ways to give legal effect to the family as it is actually lived. At the same time, it highlights how heavily a child’s legal security can depend on nationality, foreign law and how that law is interpreted. What the family in question achieved may well be out of reach for others in similar circumstances.

Maya Dougoud
Maya Dougoud
Abstract

Prompted by several parliamentary proposals to tighten the law on deepfakes, this contribution examines the phenomenon and shows how the proposals tackle the risks of artificial intelligence at different points along the chain. Together, they sketch out a multi-layered legal response: preventing risks, holding providers liable, imposing criminal sanctions, protecting victims, requiring transparency about synthetic content and making society more resilient to it.

Reflections
Alexandre Fraikin
Alexandre Fraikin
Sandra Hotz
Sandra Hotz
Nils Kapferer
Nils Kapferer
Lara Torbay
Lara Torbay
Rosemarie Weibel
Lydia Walter
Lydia Walter
Abstract

In the first issue of Mala Fide, the FRI’s new journal, the editorial board turns the spotlight on itself. It explains why the name is meant as a feminist provocation, why the journal is published open access with Weblaw, who it is written for and how peer review works. The board also reflects on which areas of law feminist debate has already shaped and where blind spots remain, how it deals with disagreements within feminism, and why multilingualism lies at the heart of the journal. The conversation offers a glimpse behind the scenes and a look at where Mala Fide hopes to be in ten years’ time.

Redaktion
Abstract

A new website on the Federal Act on Gender Equality (Gender Equality Act, GEA; SR 151.1) was launched on 14 June 2026. It brings the three databases of GEA cases, previously run separately for each language region, together in a single online resource.